| Advantages of On-Site Generation of Sodium Hypochlorite |
Although the economic consideration is the
major advantage in using On- site generated Sodium Hypochlorite over the
use of other forms of Chlorination, but the technical advantages are
even greater.
The following are some of the problems
associated with using commercial grade liquid sodium hypochlorite. These
have high concentration (10-12%) of active chlorine. These are produced
by bubbling gas chlorine in Caustic soda (Sodium Hydroxide). They are
also commonly called as Liquid Chlorine. |
| Corrosion |
| The corrosion due to Commercially produced hypochlorite is a concern because of its effect on equipment. A 10 to 15% hypochlorite solution is very aggressive due to its high pH and chlorine concentration. Because of its aggressive nature, the hypochlorite solution will exploit any weakened areas in the hypochlorite piping system and may cause leaks. |
| Scaling |
| The formation of calcium carbonate scale is another concern when using commercial grade liquid hypochlorite for chlorination. Commercial grade liquid hypochlorite has a high pH. When the high pH hypochlorite solution is mixed with the dilution water, it raises the pH of the mixed water to above 9. The calcium in the water will react and precipitate out as calcium carbonate scale. Items such as pipes, valves and rotameters may scale up and no longer function properly. It is recommended that the commercial grade liquid hypochlorite not be diluted and that the smallest pipe lines, the flow rate will allow, should be used in the system. |
| Gas Production |
| Another concern with commercial grade hypochlorite is gas production. Hypochlorite loses strength over time and generates oxygen gas as it decomposes. The rate of decomposition increases with concentration, temperature, and metal catalysts. |
| Personal Safety |
| A small leak in the hypochlorite feed lines would result in the evaporation of the water and in turn the release of chlorine gas. |
| Chlorate Formation |
The final area of concern is the possibility of chlorate ion formation. Sodium hypochlorite degrades over time to form the chlorate ion (ClO3-) and oxygen (O2). The degradation of the hypochlorite solution is dependent on the strength of the solution, temperature, and the presence of metal catalysts.
Decomposition of Commercial Sodium Hypochlorite can be created by two major ways:
a). The formation of Chlorates due to high pH, 3NaOCl= 2NaOCl+NaClO3.
b). Chlorine evaporation loss due to temperature increase.
Therefore, for any given strength and temperature, over a period of time, the higher strength product will eventually be lower in available chlorine strength than the lower strength product, since its decomposition rate is greater. The American Water Works Association Research Foundation's (AWWARF) concluded that the decomposition of concentrated bleach (NaOCl) is the most probable source of chlorate production. High concentration of Chlorate is not advisable in drinking water. |
| Chlorine Comparison Chart |
| Product Form |
PH Stability |
Available Chlorine |
Form |
| Cl2 gas |
Low |
100% |
Gas |
| Sodium hypochlorite(Commercial) |
13+ |
5-10% |
Liquid |
| Calcium hypochlorite granular |
11.5 |
20% |
Dry |
| Sodium hypochlorite(On-site) |
8.7-9 |
0.8-1% |
Liquid |
|
| Now which is the ideal disinfectant? |
| a. Chlorine Gas—this is too dangerous to handle and not safe in residential areas. Most of the times, they are not available. |
| b. Bleaching Powder—or Calcium Hypochlorite is effective, but the whole process of mixing, settling and disposing off of the sludge is very messy and cumbersome. This makes the whole area dirty. More over, the bleaching powder absorbs moisture during monsoon or in wet surroundings and emits chlorine gas, making the bleaching power lose its strength. |
| c. Liquid Bleach—or Liquid Chlorine -or Sodium Hypochlorite is very effective. This is in liquid form so very easy to handle. But the commercially available Liquid Chlorine is not only expensive but looses its strength over a period of time and becomes water. The danger of spillage is a common problem. |
| d. Electro Chlorinator—Very effective,economical, safe and easy to prepare and use. This is the latest technology being adopted in most nations. |
| |
Tell us about your requirements and our design team will be delighted to create a customized solution for you. Contact us here. |